| Presentation | 2013-05-24 A Functional Comparison of ONE Simulator and Scenargie for DTN Shigeru KANEDA, Taka MAENO, Mineo TAKAI, Shigeru KASHIHARA, Hirozumi YAMAGUCHI, Teruo HIGASHINO, |
|---|---|
| PDF Download Page |  PDF download Page Link |
| Abstract(in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Abstract(in English) | This paper compares the features of two existing simulators, namely The ONE simulator and Scenargie, for simulation of Delay/Disruption Tolerant Networks (DTNs). Several advantages and disadvantages of each simulator in the following steps of performing a simulation study have been identified: 1) scenario data creation, 2) simulation execution, and 3) visualization and analysis of yielded simulation results. In summary, The ONE simulator provides various well-known DTN routing protocols for convenience of the users, but it overly abstracts out wireless communication system stack, which may result in inaccurate simulation results. Therefore, it should also provide higher fidelity communication system models, or should be used with another network simulator for more realistic simulation results. Scenargie, on the other hand, provides high fidelity communication system models, as well as user-friendly scenario creation, visualization and data analysis capabilities through its GUI, but it currently offers few DTN specific routing protocols. It needs to provide more DTN routing protocols such that users can easily perform comparative studies on existing DTN algorithms with little efforts. |
| Keyword(in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Keyword(in English) | DTN(Delay/Disruption Tolerant Network) / simulator / ONE / Scenargie / wireless network |
| Paper # | MoNA2013-7 |
| Date of Issue |
| Conference Information | |
| Committee | MoNA |
|---|---|
| Conference Date | 2013/5/16(1days) |
| Place (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Place (in English) | |
| Topics (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Topics (in English) | |
| Chair | |
| Vice Chair | |
| Secretary | |
| Assistant | |
| Paper Information | |
| Registration To | Mobile Network and Applications(MoNA) |
|---|---|
| Language | JPN |
| Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Sub Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Title (in English) | A Functional Comparison of ONE Simulator and Scenargie for DTN |
| Sub Title (in English) | |
| Keyword(1) | DTN(Delay/Disruption Tolerant Network) |
| Keyword(2) | simulator |
| Keyword(3) | ONE |
| Keyword(4) | Scenargie |
| Keyword(5) | wireless network |
| 1st Author's Name | Shigeru KANEDA |
| 1st Author's Affiliation | Space-Time Engineering, LLC.:Graduate School of Information Science and Technology, Osaka University() |
| 2nd Author's Name | Taka MAENO |
| 2nd Author's Affiliation | Space-Time Engineering Japan, Inc. |
| 3rd Author's Name | Mineo TAKAI |
| 3rd Author's Affiliation | Graduate School of Information Science and Technology, Osaka University:Dept. of Computer Science, University of California |
| 4th Author's Name | Shigeru KASHIHARA |
| 4th Author's Affiliation | Graduate School of Information Science, Nara Institute of Science and Technology |
| 5th Author's Name | Hirozumi YAMAGUCHI |
| 5th Author's Affiliation | Graduate School of Information Science and Technology, Osaka University |
| 6th Author's Name | Teruo HIGASHINO |
| 6th Author's Affiliation | Graduate School of Information Science and Technology, Osaka University |
| Date | 2013-05-24 |
| Paper # | MoNA2013-7 |
| Volume (vol) | vol.113 |
| Number (no) | 56 |
| Page | pp.pp.- |
| #Pages | 5 |
| Date of Issue | |