| Presentation | 2021-03-05 Reputation-Based Reward Distribution Mechanism for Blockchain-Based Scientific Paper Publishing Systems Yoshiro Minamoto, Yuanyu Zhang, Masahiro Sasabe, Shoji Kasahara, |
|---|---|
| PDF Download Page |  PDF download Page Link |
| Abstract(in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Abstract(in English) | In traditional publishing systems of scientific papers, publishing companies serve as intermediaries between authors, reviewers and readers. The existence of publishing companies usually introduces heavy monetary cost to both readers and authors, and delays the proliferation of new scientific findings. To solve these problems, research efforts have been devoted to seeking alternatives of publishing companies, among which blockchain-based publishing systems have attracted considerable attention. One representative blockchain-based publishing system is called EUREKA, which relies on a reward system to distribute reward to the participants involved in the publication process. The EUREKA reward system distributes almost constant amounts of reward to reviewers without considering the quality of the reviews and the reputation of reviewers, resulting in poor incentive for reviewers and unfair reward distribution. In this paper, we aim to improve the EUREKA reward system by incorporating the reputation of reviewers and the quality of their reviews. To achieve this goal, we first design a reputation evaluation scheme, which calculates the reputation of a reviewer based on several metrics, like the number and quality of published papers and the number and quality of reviews. We then propose a reputation-based reward system that enables the reward to be distributed to reviewers based on their reputations and the quality of their reviews. Through simulations of the publication process using Web of Science data, we show the difference of reward distribution between the EUREKA-based method and the proposed method. |
| Keyword(in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Keyword(in English) | Publishing system / Reputation system / Reward system / Ethereum Blockchain |
| Paper # | NS2020-171 |
| Date of Issue | 2021-02-25 (NS) |
| Conference Information | |
| Committee | IN / NS |
|---|---|
| Conference Date | 2021/3/4(2days) |
| Place (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Place (in English) | Online |
| Topics (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Topics (in English) | General |
| Chair | Kenji Ishida(Hiroshima City Univ.) / Akihiro Nakao(Univ. of Tokyo) |
| Vice Chair | Kunio Hato(Internet Multifeed) / Tetsuya Oishi(NTT) |
| Secretary | Kunio Hato(Hiroshima City Univ.) / Tetsuya Oishi(KDDI Research) |
| Assistant | / Shinya Kawano(NTT) |
| Paper Information | |
| Registration To | Technical Committee on Information Networks / Technical Committee on Network Systems |
|---|---|
| Language | ENG-JTITLE |
| Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Sub Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Title (in English) | Reputation-Based Reward Distribution Mechanism for Blockchain-Based Scientific Paper Publishing Systems |
| Sub Title (in English) | |
| Keyword(1) | Publishing system |
| Keyword(2) | Reputation system |
| Keyword(3) | Reward system |
| Keyword(4) | Ethereum Blockchain |
| 1st Author's Name | Yoshiro Minamoto |
| 1st Author's Affiliation | Nara Institute of Science and Technology(NAIST) |
| 2nd Author's Name | Yuanyu Zhang |
| 2nd Author's Affiliation | Nara Institute of Science and Technology(NAIST) |
| 3rd Author's Name | Masahiro Sasabe |
| 3rd Author's Affiliation | Nara Institute of Science and Technology(NAIST) |
| 4th Author's Name | Shoji Kasahara |
| 4th Author's Affiliation | Nara Institute of Science and Technology(NAIST) |
| Date | 2021-03-05 |
| Paper # | NS2020-171 |
| Volume (vol) | vol.120 |
| Number (no) | NS-413 |
| Page | pp.pp.287-292(NS), |
| #Pages | 6 |
| Date of Issue | 2021-02-25 (NS) |