| IEICE Technical Committee Submission System Conference Paper's Information |
Online Proceedings [Sign in] Tech. Rep. Archives |
| Go Top Page | Go Previous | [Japanese] / [English] |
| Paper Abstract and Keywords | ||
| Presentation | 2012-01-20 10:00 Effects of lawyer's argument on deliberation process in mock trial -- the frequency and the contents of reference to the final argument in deliberation -- Ayumu Arakawa (MAU)  HCS2011-53 |
|
| Abstract | (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| (in English) | To examine the impact of the defense attorney’s final argument in the Saiban-in system, a mock saiban-in deliberation which was participated by 24 undergraduates as lay judges and 3 law-school graduates as professional judges was conducted. The deliberations were based on one of the two scenarios which include different final arguments (story type or story and logic type). The purpose of this research is to examine the presence or absence of the impact of argument, and its reason through the analysis of the frequency and the contents of reference to the argument in deliberation. As a result, the saiban-in referred to the argument only about 1.83 times in a deliberation. The contents of reference were the “evaluation of the reality of the defense story,” “confirmation of the defense claim,” and “reference to the legal standard in the defense claim.” The result suggests that the impact of the final argument has an extremely light impact on the jury’s decision making except offering judgmental standards. | |
| Keyword | (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| (in English) | Mixed jury system (Saiban-in System) / deliberation / Expert-Lay communication / / / / / | |
| Reference Info. | IEICE Tech. Rep., vol. 111, no. 393, HCS2011-53, pp. 1-4, Jan. 2012. | |
| Paper # | HCS2011-53 | |
| Date of Issue | 2012-01-13 (HCS) | |
| ISSN | Print edition: ISSN 0913-5685 Online edition: ISSN 2432-6380 | |
| Copyright and reproduction |
All rights are reserved and no part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Notwithstanding, instructors are permitted to photocopy isolated articles for noncommercial classroom use without fee. (License No.: 10GA0019/12GB0052/13GB0056/17GB0034/18GB0034) | |
| Download PDF | HCS2011-53 |
|
| Conference Information | |
| Committee | HCS |
| Conference Date | 2012-01-20 - 2012-01-20 |
| Place (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Place (in English) | |
| Topics (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Topics (in English) | |
| Paper Information | |
| Registration To | HCS |
| Conference Code | 2012-01-HCS |
| Language | Japanese |
| Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Sub Title (in Japanese) | (See Japanese page) |
| Title (in English) | Effects of lawyer's argument on deliberation process in mock trial |
| Sub Title (in English) | the frequency and the contents of reference to the final argument in deliberation |
| Keyword(1) | Mixed jury system (Saiban-in System) |
| Keyword(2) | deliberation |
| Keyword(3) | Expert-Lay communication |
| Keyword(4) | |
| Keyword(5) | |
| Keyword(6) | |
| Keyword(7) | |
| Keyword(8) | |
| 1st Author's Name | Ayumu Arakawa |
| 1st Author's Affiliation | Musashino Art University (MAU) |
| 2nd Author's Name | |
| 2nd Author's Affiliation | () |
| 3rd Author's Name | |
| 3rd Author's Affiliation | () |
| 4th Author's Name | |
| 4th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 5th Author's Name | |
| 5th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 6th Author's Name | |
| 6th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 7th Author's Name | |
| 7th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 8th Author's Name | |
| 8th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 9th Author's Name | |
| 9th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 10th Author's Name | |
| 10th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 11th Author's Name | |
| 11th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 12th Author's Name | |
| 12th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 13th Author's Name | |
| 13th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 14th Author's Name | |
| 14th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 15th Author's Name | |
| 15th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 16th Author's Name | |
| 16th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 17th Author's Name | |
| 17th Author's Affiliation | () |
| 18th Author's Name | |
| 18th Author's Affiliation | () |
| Speaker | Author-1 |
| Date Time | 2012-01-20 10:00:00 |
| Presentation Time | 30 minutes |
| Registration for | HCS |
| Paper # | HCS2011-53 |
| Volume (vol) | vol.111 |
| Number (no) | no.393 |
| Page | pp.1-4 |
| #Pages | 4 |
| Date of Issue | 2012-01-13 (HCS) |
[Return to Top Page]